$0 CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist

CMS Annual Review Reconsideration

How the CMS Annual Review Works

Every 12 months, the Child Maintenance Service automatically recalculates maintenance using updated gross income data pulled from HMRC. The CMS does not ask either parent before running this review — it pulls the latest available tax year figures and applies the standard calculation formula.

You receive a new decision letter showing the revised weekly amount. If the HMRC data has changed since the previous year, your maintenance could go up, down, or stay the same.

Why Annual Reviews Go Wrong

The annual review is only as accurate as the HMRC data behind it. Common problems include:

  • Stale income figures: HMRC's records reflect the most recent completed tax year. If your income dropped significantly this year, last year's higher figure still drives the calculation until the next annual review or a successful change-of-circumstances report.
  • One-off income spikes: A taxable part of a redundancy payment, a large bonus, or the sale of business assets in the previous tax year inflates gross income above your normal earnings.
  • Self-employment timing: Self-assessment figures land at HMRC on a different schedule than PAYE records. The CMS may pick up an outdated or incomplete figure.
  • Multiple employments: Income from a job you no longer hold can still be part of the correct figure if it falls within the tax year CMS used. Challenge this if HMRC's figure or the tax year used was wrong.

Challenging the Annual Review Decision

If the new calculation letter contains an error, you can request a mandatory reconsideration within 30 days of the date printed on the decision letter. The process is the same as for any other CMS decision:

  1. Identify the specific error — which income figure is wrong, which tax year it relates to, and what the correct figure should be
  2. Gather evidence — your P60, consecutive payslips, SA302 tax calculation, or employer contract showing actual current earnings
  3. Submit through an official channel — the CMS online account, by phone on 0800 171 2345, or by post to Mail Handling Site A, Wolverhampton WV98 2BU

State clearly that you are requesting a mandatory reconsideration of the annual review decision, and reference the exact date and calculation figure on the letter.

Free Download

Get the CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist

Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.

When a Change of Circumstances Is the Right Route Instead

A mandatory reconsideration challenges whether the CMS applied the existing data correctly. If your income has genuinely changed since the tax year the CMS used — a job loss, reduced hours, retirement — you may need to report a change of circumstances instead.

The CMS uses current income only when it differs from the HMRC figure by at least 25%. Below that threshold, the historic tax year figure stands regardless of your actual current pay.

If you are unsure which route applies, our CMS Mandatory Reconsideration guide explains how to tell the difference and what evidence each route requires.

Do Not Wait for HMRC to Fix It

A common mistake: discovering the HMRC income figure is wrong and contacting HMRC to amend your tax return, then waiting for the correction to flow through to the CMS. This does not pause your 30-day mandatory reconsideration deadline. If HMRC later amends the historic income information CMS used, DWP guidance says the CMS can revise the calculation from the original decision's effective date; tell the CMS about the amendment rather than assuming it has updated the case.

File the mandatory reconsideration request now, attach whatever evidence you have, and note that an HMRC amendment is in progress. You can supply the corrected SA302 as supplementary evidence once HMRC processes it.

Get Your Free CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist

Download the CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.

Learn More →