Child Maintenance Arrears Reconsideration UK
How CMS Arrears Accumulate
Arrears build up whenever the paying parent's actual payments fall short of the calculated liability. This can happen because:
- Payments were missed entirely
- The paying parent paid less than the required amount
- A backdated decision increased the liability retroactively, creating an instant shortfall
- A variation or supersession applied a higher rate from an earlier effective date
Under Direct Pay, the CMS cannot take action while that arrangement remains in place; the receiving parent can ask to move to Collect & Pay. Under Collect & Pay, the CMS tracks missed payments and can seek to recover arrears through enforcement, including a Deduction from Earnings Order or an application for a liability order through the courts.
Challenging Arrears Through Mandatory Reconsideration
You cannot appeal to a tribunal about the level of collection for arrears as a standalone issue. If the CMS payment record or arrears balance is wrong, contact CMS with proof of payments. If the maintenance calculation that created the arrears was wrong, request a mandatory reconsideration of that calculation decision.
The route is to request a mandatory reconsideration of the original calculation decision that generated the arrears. If the CMS revises the calculation downward, the arrears figure recalculates automatically.
For example, if the CMS used an incorrect HMRC income figure and you successfully challenge it, the revised maintenance amount normally applies from the effective date of the decision it replaces. The arrears accumulated during that period may shrink or disappear. If you overpaid based on the incorrect figure, you can ask the CMS for reimbursement; there is no automatic right to a refund or credit.
When Arrears Come From a Backdated Decision
Sometimes the CMS issues a decision that applies retroactively — a variation assessment, a late supersession, or a correction from an annual review. This can create thousands of pounds in instant arrears that the paying parent had no way to anticipate.
If the backdated decision itself was wrong — wrong income data, incorrect effective date, or a variation applied on flawed grounds — you can challenge it through mandatory reconsideration within 30 days of the decision letter.
Free Download
Get the CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist
Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.
Receiving Parents and Underpaid Arrears
If you are a receiving parent and arrears have built up because the paying parent is not complying, the CMS can collect through Collect & Pay and seek a liability order through the courts. After the required court process, enforcement can include driving licence or passport restrictions.
If the CMS is not pursuing arrears actively enough, or has written off arrears you believe should still be collected, you can raise this through the CMS complaints process. A decision about the level of collection for arrears does not carry a tribunal appeal right.
Overpayments After a Successful Challenge
If a mandatory reconsideration or tribunal appeal reduces the calculation for an earlier period, the paying parent may have overpaid. You can ask the CMS for reimbursement, but it decides whether to reimburse; there is no automatic entitlement to a cash refund or account credit.
Free Debt Advice
Paying parents facing substantial arrears should contact StepChange (0800 138 1111) or National Debtline (0808 808 4000) alongside pursuing any calculation challenge. These services help manage overall household finances and can advise on priority debts. Since 30 April 2025, most deductions to repay debts from Universal Credit are capped at 15% of the standard allowance. Child maintenance has priority over other listed third-party deductions, a rule made permanent from 30 April 2026, and as a last-resort deduction can exceed that cap.
Our CMS Mandatory Reconsideration guide covers how to challenge the underlying calculation that drives arrears, with step-by-step evidence checklists.
Get Your Free CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist
Download the CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.