$0 CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist

CMS Income Change and Bonus Reconsideration

How Bonuses and Income Changes Affect Calculations

The CMS calculates maintenance using gross income from HMRC records — typically the most recent completed tax year. If that year included a one-off bonus, significant overtime, or a temporary income spike, the resulting maintenance figure may be higher than your normal earnings would produce.

This is one of the most common complaints paying parents have. A single large bonus can inflate the gross income figure by thousands of pounds, lifting the maintenance calculation well above what your regular salary alone would generate.

Can You Challenge a Bonus-Inflated Calculation?

It depends on whether the HMRC figure is wrong or just unrepresentative.

If HMRC correctly recorded your gross earnings for that tax year — including the bonus — the CMS has used the right data. The calculation is technically correct even if it feels unfair. A mandatory reconsideration on these facts alone is unlikely to succeed because the CMS applied the law as written.

However, if the income figure or tax year the CMS used is wrong, you can request a mandatory reconsideration. A one-off bonus or earnings from a job you no longer hold do not by themselves mean the historic HMRC figure is wrong.

The 25% Current Income Rule

If your current income is at least 25% lower (or higher) than the HMRC historic figure, you can ask the CMS to use your current income instead. This is not a mandatory reconsideration — it is a change of circumstances report. The CMS will verify your current earnings through payslips or other evidence and, if the 25% threshold is met, recalculate going forward.

If the difference is under 25%, the HMRC historic figure stands until the next annual review pulls in a more recent tax year.

Free Download

Get the CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist

Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.

What Evidence to Provide

For a mandatory reconsideration (challenging incorrect data):

  • P60 showing what was actually earned vs what HMRC recorded
  • Payslips isolating the bonus from regular salary
  • Employer letter confirming the bonus was a one-off, non-recurring payment
  • SA302 if self-employed, showing the corrected income breakdown

For a change of circumstances (current income differs by 25%+):

  • Three consecutive recent payslips showing current actual earnings
  • Employer contract confirming your current salary
  • P45 if you have left the job where the bonus was earned

Receiving Parents: When Income Goes Up

If you believe the paying parent received a substantial pay rise, bonus, or new income source after the last calculation, the route is a change of circumstances report — not a mandatory reconsideration. You are reporting a new fact, not challenging the accuracy of an old decision.

If the paying parent is diverting income through a company (low salary, high retained profits), the variation route is more appropriate than either a mandatory reconsideration or a change of circumstances report.

Acting Within the Deadline

For a mandatory reconsideration, the deadline is 30 days from the date on the CMS decision letter. Some changes of circumstances have reporting deadlines. For example, if the CMS uses a gross income figure supplied directly by the paying parent, their employer, or their accountant, a paying parent must report an income increase of 25% or more within 7 days if the increase is likely to remain the same for the foreseeable future. If reported late, payments may be backdated to the date the change happened; the effective date depends on the type of change.

Our CMS Mandatory Reconsideration guide helps you determine which route applies and walks through the evidence needed for each.

Get Your Free CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist

Download the CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.

Learn More →