Your CMS letter says you owe more than you should — or less than your child needs. You have 30 days to challenge it.
The Child Maintenance Service sends a decision letter. The figure looks wrong. You check GOV.UK, Citizens Advice, Reddit — and every page says "explain why the decision is wrong" without showing you how.
Meanwhile the deadline is running. Miss it and the calculation stands. Challenge it badly — a phone call with no record, the wrong form, evidence that doesn't match the disputed input — and you get a rejection that arrives faster than the original decision did.
The CMS Decision Audit System
This guide replaces scattered government pages and forum guesswork with a single, structured workflow that takes you from the decision letter to the outcome — and, if the CMS says no, through to the tribunal appeal.
It is written for both parents. Whether you are the paying parent facing an unfair increase or the receiving parent watching accurate maintenance disappear, the process is the same. The guide covers it from both sides, without taking sides.
What's Inside
- Decision letter decoder — which CMS decisions qualify for a mandatory reconsideration and which need a different route (variation, change of circumstances, complaint), so you don't waste your deadline on the wrong process
- Deadline tracker — the 30-day window, the late-request rules beyond it, and what counts as a good reason for delay, with a dated timeline you fill in from your own letter
- Evidence-to-input matching — for each disputed input (gross income, shared care, additional children, special expenses) the guide names the evidence the CMS actually weighs and the documents it ignores, so your submission addresses the right data point
- Three-channel submission protocol — requests by telephone or in writing, and how to use the online account if your decision letter directs you there; keep a dated record and track postal delivery
- Counter-evidence framework for the other parent — if your ex has applied for a reconsideration, the guide explains your right to submit your own evidence, what the CMS shares with you, and how to respond before the review closes
- HMRC income walkthrough — why the CMS figure often comes from last year's tax data, how to check it, and when the 25% current-income threshold lets you request a recalculation using this year's earnings
- Outcome letter and what comes next — the Mandatory Reconsideration Notice, what it means if the decision changes or stays, and the step-by-step hand-off to a First-tier Tribunal appeal using Form SSCS2
- Domestic-safety chapter — alternative submission routes, evidence handling, and third-party representation for parents who cannot safely contact the CMS through the standard channels
The guide also includes worksheets, a contacts directory (Citizens Advice, Gingerbread, legal aid, StepChange, Family Mediation Council), and a chapter on the announced CMS reforms — Direct Pay removal, Collect & Pay fees, the income-change threshold — so you know what has changed and what is still proposed.
Who This Is For
- Paying parents whose calculation includes the wrong income, doesn't reflect your shared-care nights, or misses children in your current household
- Receiving parents whose award has dropped because the paying parent reported lower income, claimed more overnight care than they provide, or switched to self-employment
- Either parent responding to a reconsideration the other parent has started — the guide covers both initiating and responding
- Family members or new partners helping a parent who is overwhelmed by the process or close to the deadline
Why Not Just Use GOV.UK?
The official guidance tells you that you can challenge a decision. It does not show you how to build a submission that survives the internal review. Parents on r/LegalAdviceUK describe mandatory reconsiderations rejected within 24 hours — sometimes because they sent a narrative statement instead of matching their evidence to the specific input the CMS got wrong.
Citizens Advice explains the right clearly. What it cannot do, because every bureau is under-resourced, is sit with you while you assemble the evidence bundle, log the submission, and prepare for the tribunal if the CMS says no.
The guide fills that gap: a printable workflow that organises the evidence, records every submission, and structures the hand-off to the tribunal — without charging solicitor rates.
Free Checklist Included
Not sure where you stand? Download the free CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist first. It covers the deadline, the evidence to gather, and the steps in order — enough to see whether a reconsideration is the right route for your situation.
When you are ready for the full guide — the evidence matching, submission templates, counter-evidence framework, HMRC income walkthrough, and tribunal preparation — the complete guide is here.
Full Refund, No Time Limit
If the guide is not what you expected, email [email protected] for a full refund. No time limit, no questions, no forms.
This guide is an independent educational publication. It is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or connected to the Child Maintenance Service (CMS), the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP), or HM Courts & Tribunals Service (HMCTS).
Frequently Asked Questions
What if the rules change after I buy?
We update the guide when the rules change. Email us any time, even years later, and we'll send you the current edition free.