$0 CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist

CMS Self-Employed Income Challenge

Why Self-Employment Makes CMS Calculations Complicated

The CMS calculates maintenance using gross income data from HMRC. For employed parents, this is usually straightforward — PAYE records are updated regularly. For self-employed parents, the picture is murkier.

HMRC's self-assessment figures often run 12 to 18 months behind the current tax year. A self-employed parent whose business had a strong year two years ago but is struggling now will still see that older, higher figure in the CMS calculation. Conversely, a parent who recently started earning significantly more through their business may show a low historic figure that understates their actual income.

Mandatory Reconsideration vs Variation

This distinction matters. They address different problems:

Mandatory reconsideration is for when the CMS applied the existing data incorrectly — it used the wrong tax year, misread an SA302, included income that belongs to a business partner, or made a mathematical error. You are saying "the data you used was wrong" or "you applied it incorrectly."

A variation application (under section 28G of the Child Support Act 1991 for an existing calculation, applying the section 28A variation rules) is for when the HMRC figure is technically correct but does not reflect the paying parent's true financial position. This covers income diversion (paying yourself a low salary while retaining profits in the company), unearned income (rental, dividends, investment returns), and lifestyle inconsistent with declared earnings.

If you are a receiving parent who suspects the other parent earns far more than their tax return shows, a mandatory reconsideration alone will not help — you need the variation route.

Evidence for Self-Employed Challenges

If you are the self-employed parent challenging your own calculation:

  • SA302 tax calculation from HMRC for the relevant year — this is the definitive document showing what HMRC recorded
  • Full trading accounts prepared by an accountant, showing gross turnover, allowable expenses, and net profit
  • Bank statements for the business account covering the relevant period
  • Contracts or invoices showing the work you actually performed and billed

If your self-assessment has been amended or you filed late, bring evidence of both the original and corrected figures.

Free Download

Get the CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist

Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.

The 25% Income Threshold

A detail that catches many self-employed parents: the CMS will only use a current income figure instead of the HMRC historic figure if the difference is at least 25%. If your income dropped by 15%, the CMS will not adjust the calculation based on current earnings alone — the historic figure stands until the next annual review pulls in a newer tax year.

If you are within the 25% threshold but your self-assessment data was genuinely misrecorded at HMRC, the mandatory reconsideration route still applies because the dispute is about the accuracy of the data, not about a change in circumstances.

The 30-Day Deadline

Request the mandatory reconsideration within 30 days of the date on the CMS decision letter. Submit through the CMS online account, by phone on 0800 171 2345, or by post to Mail Handling Site A, Wolverhampton WV98 2BU.

Do not wait for HMRC to process a tax amendment before filing. Mention that an amendment is in progress and supply what evidence you have now — you can send supplementary documents later.

Our CMS Mandatory Reconsideration guide explains both the standard challenge and when to escalate to a variation application, with evidence checklists for each route.

Get Your Free CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist

Download the CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.

Learn More →