CMS HMRC Income Wrong: How to Challenge an Incorrect Earnings Figure
Why HMRC Figures Don't Always Reflect Reality
The CMS calculates child maintenance using gross income information from HMRC. It usually uses the latest available figure as the starting point for the calculation unless there's a reason to use something else.
The problem is that HMRC records can be wrong, outdated, or misleading:
- A difference between historic and current income — a one-off bonus or overtime may make the tax-year figure differ from current earnings, but that alone does not make the CMS calculation wrong. The taxable part of a redundancy payment can count as historic income, but not as current income.
- A job change means HMRC still shows income from the old employer, potentially at a very different level
- Tax return errors where self-employment profits were miscalculated or a capital gain was wrongly classified as salary
- Late filing where the most recent tax year data hasn't been processed yet, so the CMS is using an older figure
One common scenario described on UK legal forums: a paying parent's CMS calculation was based on HMRC showing £45,000 of gross income, but that figure included a one-off capital gain that shouldn't have been counted as regular salary. The fix required a mandatory reconsideration with SA302 forms and an accountant's statement.
Correcting HMRC Won't Automatically Fix the CMS
This is a critical point. If the HMRC figure is wrong, your instinct might be to contact HMRC and correct your tax return. That's worth doing — but it won't trigger the CMS to recalculate. The two systems don't automatically sync in real time.
You need to request a mandatory reconsideration directly with the CMS, and you need to do it within 30 days of the decision letter. Supply copies of the corrected documents (SA302 tax calculations, payslips, employment contracts) as evidence to the CMS, while separately pursuing the HMRC correction in parallel.
Don't wait for HMRC to process your amendment before filing with the CMS. The 30-day deadline runs regardless.
What Evidence to Gather
For employed parents:
- P60 for the relevant tax year showing actual gross earnings
- P45 from a previous employer if the job has changed
- Three to six consecutive monthly payslips showing current income
- Employment contract confirming current salary
For self-employed parents:
- SA302 tax calculation from HMRC (this is the official summary of your self-assessment)
- Full self-assessment tax return
- Audited trading accounts if available
For income changes: The CMS can use current income instead of historic tax data if the current figure is at least 25% higher or lower than the HMRC record and the change is likely to be permanent or long-term. Supply evidence of your current earnings alongside the historic correction.
Free Download
Get the CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist
Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.
The 25% Threshold
Under the CMS rules, if you provide a current income figure that differs by less than 25% from the HMRC historic figure, the CMS will generally stick with the HMRC data. The income change must reach at least 25% and be likely to be permanent or long-term before the CMS uses current earnings as the basis for calculation.
This matters because a moderate income drop — say, from £40,000 to £35,000 — won't be enough on its own. But if the HMRC figure was wrong in the first place (not just lower now), you're challenging the accuracy of the original input, which is a different basis for reconsideration.
How to Request the Reconsideration
Submit through your My Child Maintenance Case account, by phone on 0800 171 2345, or by post to Child Maintenance Service 21, Mail Handling Site A, Wolverhampton, WV98 2BU. Identify the specific decision, explain that the HMRC income figure is incorrect, state what the correct figure should be, and attach your evidence.
For a full guide to challenging income errors — including evidence checklists and deadline trackers — see our CMS Mandatory Reconsideration guide.
Get Your Free CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist
Download the CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.