$0 CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist

Receiving Parent Mandatory Reconsideration CMS

Why Receiving Parents Challenge CMS Decisions

As the receiving parent (called the person with care in CMS terminology), you can request a mandatory reconsideration if you believe the CMS calculation is too low. Typical triggers include:

  • Understated paying parent income: the other parent earns more than what HMRC records show — perhaps from cash-in-hand work, a recent pay rise not yet reflected in tax records, or dividends from a company they control
  • Wrong shared care band: the CMS recorded more overnight stays with the paying parent than actually happen, reducing the maintenance amount
  • Missing the paying parent's other income: rental income, investment returns, or earnings from a second job that HMRC data may not fully capture

If the issue is hidden income or money routed through a business structure, a mandatory reconsideration alone may not be enough. For an existing calculation, you may need a variation application under section 28G of the Child Support Act 1991, which applies the section 28A variation rules — a separate process for circumstances such as unearned income and income diversion.

Responding When the Other Parent Files

You may also find yourself on the other side: the paying parent has requested a mandatory reconsideration to reduce the maintenance amount. The CMS will send you a copy of their submission (with personal details redacted) and give you a window to respond with your own evidence.

This is your chance to protect the current calculation. If the paying parent claims fewer overnight stays than actually happen, or says their income has dropped, you can submit evidence showing otherwise. Do not assume the CMS will check the paying parent's claims independently — your response matters.

For an overnight shared-care dispute, CMS accepts a current court order, a formal agreement such as one made through a solicitor, or another official document such as one from CAFCASS or social services. It does not accept parent-to-parent messages, photos, social media screenshots, calendar entries, or school records as evidence of overnight stays.

The 30-Day Window

Whether you are filing a challenge or responding to one, timing is critical. You have 30 days from the date on the CMS decision letter to request a mandatory reconsideration. If the paying parent filed and the CMS sends you their evidence, respond within the timeframe given (typically 14 days) — missing it means the decision maker may proceed without hearing your side.

Submit through the CMS online account, by phone on 0800 171 2345, or by post to Mail Handling Site A, Wolverhampton WV98 2BU.

Free Download

Get the CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist

Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.

Payments During the Review

The existing maintenance amount remains in force while the mandatory reconsideration is being processed. The paying parent is legally required to keep paying at the current rate. If the arrangement is Direct Pay and the paying parent stops paying or reduces payments, the CMS cannot enforce those arrears while Direct Pay remains in place. You can ask the CMS to switch the case to Collect & Pay, where the CMS collects and enforces payments.

If you are relying on maintenance to cover essential costs and payments have stopped, contact Citizens Advice (free). Gingerbread's Advice Service closed on 1 April 2025; its information pages and community membership remain available.

Planning for Every Outcome

The CMS can revise the calculation up or down, or uphold it unchanged. If the outcome is not what you expected, you have a further right to appeal to the First-tier Tribunal using Form SSCS2 — this is free and independent of the CMS.

Our CMS Mandatory Reconsideration guide covers the full process for both parents, including evidence checklists and preparation for a tribunal appeal.

Get Your Free CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist

Download the CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.

Learn More →