$0 CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist

Best CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Guide for Paying Parents

What Paying Parents Need From a Guide

If you're the paying parent and the CMS calculation looks wrong, your situation has a specific shape. You're probably dealing with one of these: HMRC reported an income figure that includes a one-off bonus or overtime that won't recur, the CMS didn't apply the shared care reduction you're entitled to, children in your current household weren't counted, or pension contributions were left out. And underneath the calculation dispute sits the enforcement risk — a 20% collection surcharge if the case moves to Collect & Pay, and the possibility of a Deduction from Earnings Order if you fall behind on what the CMS says you owe.

A good guide for paying parents covers both sides: how to challenge the number, and how to protect yourself from enforcement while the challenge is being processed.

The Three Things That Matter Most

1. Evidence That Matches Your Disputed Input

The single biggest mistake paying parents make is sending a general letter explaining why the calculation feels unfair. The CMS doesn't review feelings — it reviews inputs. A reconsideration succeeds when you identify which specific data point is wrong and supply the documents that prove it.

For income disputes (the most common for paying parents):

  • Last year's income was unusually high: Supply your current employment contract alongside the P60 that shows the anomaly. If your current gross income is at least 25% lower than the HMRC figure, you can request the CMS uses your current income instead.
  • Self-employment income was overstated: Provide your SA302 Tax Calculation Summary from HMRC and audited trading accounts. Generic bank statements don't work.
  • Pension contributions weren't deducted: SIPP contribution certificates or employer pension statements showing the gross deduction.

For shared care disputes:

  • For overnight shared care, the CMS can accept a current court order, a formal agreement such as one drawn up by a solicitor, or another official document such as one from CAFCASS or social services. It cannot accept parent-to-parent communications, including WhatsApp messages, photos, social-media screenshots, or calendar entries as evidence of overnight care.

2. The 30-Day Deadline (and What Happens If You Miss It)

You have 30 days from the date on the CMS decision letter. Not 30 days from when it arrived. Not 30 days from when you opened it.

If you can't get your evidence together in time, submit a protective request before the deadline. State what you're challenging, note that supporting documents are coming, and ask for 14–28 days to supply them. A partial submission that beats the deadline is vastly better than a complete one that misses it.

If you've already missed the deadline, a late request may be accepted if you can demonstrate special circumstances — but the longer the delay, the more compelling the evidence of good cause needs to be.

3. What Happens to Payments During the Review

This is where paying parents get caught out. A common misconception is that challenging the calculation lets you reduce or stop payments while the review is in progress. It doesn't. The existing calculation stays in force during the mandatory reconsideration, and you're expected to keep paying the amount it sets. Missing payments during the review can trigger enforcement action — a Deduction from Earnings Order, a move to Collect & Pay with the 20% surcharge, or worse.

If the reconsideration succeeds and the amount goes down, you'll receive a retroactive adjustment. But in the meantime, the original amount is due.

What a Good Paying-Parent Guide Covers

The CMS Mandatory Reconsideration guide is written for both parents, but paying parents specifically need:

  • Evidence-to-input matching for income disputes — the guide maps each disputed input (gross income, self-employment, shared care, additional children, pensions) to the specific documents the CMS weighs, so your submission targets the data point that's actually wrong
  • The 25% current-income threshold — when your current earnings are at least 25% above or below the HMRC historic figure, the CMS can use current income instead; the guide explains how to trigger this
  • Counter-evidence handling — if the receiving parent has started a reconsideration that would increase your payments, you have the right to submit your own evidence; the guide covers how and when
  • HMRC income walkthrough — why the CMS figure often comes from last year's tax data, what the gap means, and how to challenge it with current payslips and contracts
  • Enforcement risk context — what stays in force during the review and how to avoid triggering collection action while the reconsideration is processed
  • Tribunal hand-off — if the CMS says no, the guide walks through Form SSCS2 and the appeal to the First-tier Tribunal

It also includes printable worksheets: a deadline calculator, an evidence schedule tracker, a submission record log, and a contacts directory for Citizens Advice, Gingerbread, legal aid, StepChange (for debt issues related to arrears), and the Family Mediation Council.

Free Download

Get the CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist

Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.

Who This Is For

  • Paying parents whose CMS calculation includes the wrong income figure — a one-off bonus, stale HMRC data, or unreported pension deductions
  • Paying parents whose shared care nights aren't reflected in the calculation
  • Paying parents responding to a reconsideration the receiving parent started
  • Family members or new partners helping a paying parent navigate the process under a tight deadline

Who This Is NOT For

  • Paying parents whose income dispute involves complex company structures, dividends, or income diversion — these typically need a variation application and may justify a solicitor
  • Anyone looking to reduce payments below what they genuinely owe — the guide navigates the process honestly for both sides
  • Paying parents in Northern Ireland — CMSNI is a separate jurisdiction with its own process

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I stop paying while the mandatory reconsideration is in progress?

No. The existing calculation stays in force during the review. You're expected to continue paying the amount the CMS set. If the reconsideration succeeds and the figure drops, the difference is adjusted retroactively. Stopping payments during the review can trigger enforcement action.

What if my income has changed since the HMRC figure the CMS used?

If your current gross income is at least 25% higher or lower than the HMRC figure the CMS used, you can ask the CMS to use your current income instead. You'll need to supply current payslips, your employment contract, and evidence of the change. The guide walks through how to present this.

My shared care isn't reflected — what evidence works?

For overnight shared care, the CMS can accept a current court order, a formal agreement such as one drawn up by a solicitor, or another official document such as one from CAFCASS or social services. It cannot accept parent-to-parent communications, including WhatsApp messages, photos, social-media screenshots, or calendar entries as evidence of overnight care.

What's the difference between a reconsideration and a change of circumstances?

A mandatory reconsideration challenges the original decision — it was wrong when it was made (wrong income year, missed shared care, etc.). A change of circumstances reports something that changed after the decision (you lost your job, your care arrangement shifted). They're different processes with different evidence requirements. Getting the wrong one delays everything.

How long does the mandatory reconsideration take?

There's no statutory time limit for the CMS to complete the review. Processing times vary — straightforward income disputes may be resolved in a few weeks, while complex cases or those requiring information from the other parent can take longer. The guide includes a tracking worksheet to monitor progress and follow up.

Get Your Free CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist

Download the CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.

Learn More →