$0 CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist

Child Maintenance Change of Circumstances UK

Change of Circumstances vs Mandatory Reconsideration

These are two separate CMS processes that parents frequently confuse. The difference matters because using the wrong one wastes time and may leave the actual problem unresolved.

Mandatory reconsideration looks backward. The CMS made a decision and you believe it was wrong at the time — incorrect income data, wrong shared care band, missing information. You are asking the CMS to review and correct a past decision.

Change of circumstances (also called supersession) looks forward. Something has genuinely changed since the last decision — a job loss, a pay rise, a child moving households, a new child born — and you want the CMS to update the calculation to reflect the new reality.

Reporting a change of circumstances to the CMS does not trigger a mandatory reconsideration. It is dealt with as a supersession. The effective date depends on the type of change. If a paying parent reports a legally reportable income increase late, the CMS may backdate payments to the date the change happened.

When to Report a Change

Some changes must be reported by law. If the CMS uses a gross income figure supplied directly by the paying parent, their employer, or their accountant, the paying parent must report within 7 days an increase of 25% or more in gross weekly income if the increase is likely to remain the same for the foreseeable future. A paying parent on the nil rate must also report within 7 days if gross weekly income reaches £7 and the increase is likely to remain the same for the foreseeable future. This 7-day income-reporting duty does not apply when the calculation uses an HMRC-supplied figure, but either parent can report an income change of 25% or more or no income.

Also report a change in who the child's main carer is, an overnight shared-care arrangement that affects payments, or changes to contact or bank details. A child leaving qualifying education or training, marrying, or entering a civil partnership can also affect when maintenance ends.

If a paying parent fails to report a legally required income change within 7 days, they may be prosecuted, fined up to £1,000, and payments may be backdated to the date the change happened. Report changes through the CMS online account or by contacting the CMS.

The Variation Route

A variation is a specific statutory mechanism for situations where the standard calculation does not capture the paying parent's true financial position. It covers:

  • Unearned income: rental property, dividends, savings interest above statutory thresholds
  • Income diversion: a paying parent who controls a business and pays themselves a low salary while retaining profits
  • Special expenses: boarding school fees, costs of maintaining contact with the child, debts from the former relationship

Variations are applied on top of the standard calculation. Either parent can apply for one. The CMS investigates and decides whether to adjust the gross income figure used in the formula.

Free Download

Get the CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist

Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.

Which Route Applies to You?

Situation Route
CMS used the wrong tax year or misread HMRC data Mandatory reconsideration
CMS recorded wrong number of overnight stays at the time of the decision Mandatory reconsideration
You just lost your job and income has dropped since the decision Change of circumstances
The paying parent starts supporting another child who is taken into account in the calculation Change of circumstances
The other parent earns dividends and rental income not in HMRC figures Variation application
The other parent runs a business and suppresses their salary Variation application

If you have received a CMS decision letter that was wrong from the start, the mandatory reconsideration is the right route. You have 30 days from the date on the letter to submit.

Our CMS Mandatory Reconsideration guide explains the full challenge process including evidence requirements and what happens after the CMS issues its decision.

Get Your Free CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist

Download the CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.

Learn More →