Best CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Guide for Receiving Parents
Why Receiving Parents Need Different Guidance
When you're the receiving parent, a CMS mandatory reconsideration usually hits you in one of two ways. Either the paying parent has challenged the calculation — asking for a lower figure — and you've been told to respond. Or the CMS made a decision that reduced your maintenance unexpectedly, and you need to challenge it yourself. Each scenario has its own evidence requirements and risks.
The hardest part for receiving parents is the asymmetry. The paying parent has direct access to their own payslips, tax returns, and employment records. You often have to disprove claims about income or shared care using evidence you don't directly control. A good guide accounts for that gap and shows you what evidence you can realistically obtain and how to present it.
Scenario 1: The Paying Parent Has Challenged the Calculation
You receive a letter saying the other parent has requested a mandatory reconsideration. The existing calculation stays in force while the CMS reviews the decision — the paying parent is still required to pay the current amount. But you have a right to submit your own evidence before the review closes, and exercising that right matters.
What to do:
Read the notification carefully. It tells you what the paying parent is disputing. Common grounds include claiming lower income, arguing for more shared care nights, or reporting additional children in their household.
Gather counter-evidence for the specific disputed input. If the paying parent claims reduced income, any evidence you have of their actual financial situation helps — job advertisements they've posted, social media showing lifestyle indicators, evidence of a new business. For disputed overnight shared care, the CMS can accept a current court order, a formal agreement such as one drawn up by a solicitor, or another official document such as one from CAFCASS or social services; it cannot use your own dated records, parent-to-parent communications, photos, social-media screenshots, or calendar entries as evidence of overnight care.
Submit within the timeframe the CMS gives you. The notification letter sets a window for your response. Don't miss it — once the review closes, the decision is made on whatever evidence the CMS has.
Keep a record of everything you submit. Screenshot online submissions, keep postal tracking receipts, note call dates and agent names.
Scenario 2: You Need to Challenge a Decision Yourself
Your maintenance dropped because the paying parent reported a change in circumstances, or the annual review pulled a lower income figure from HMRC. If you believe the new figure is wrong, you can request a mandatory reconsideration yourself. The 30-day deadline from the date on the decision letter applies to you just as it does to the paying parent.
Common triggers for receiving parents:
- The paying parent reported lower self-employment income that you believe is understated
- The paying parent claimed more shared care nights than they actually provide
- The CMS annual review used an HMRC income figure that doesn't reflect the paying parent's real earnings (they switched from employment to self-employment, or declared minimal salary through a company)
- Income from a new partner was incorrectly factored in (it shouldn't be — only the qualifying parent's income counts in the standard calculation)
The evidence challenge: You need to demonstrate that the paying parent's income or circumstances are different from what they declared, often without direct access to their financial records. What works:
- Evidence of the paying parent's lifestyle that's inconsistent with declared income (new car, holidays, property purchases — these support a variation application for income diversion)
- Records from Companies House showing directorships or significant shareholdings
- Job advertisements or LinkedIn profiles indicating higher-paid employment
- A current court order, formal agreement, or other official document showing the overnight arrangement
For income-diversion cases — where the paying parent controls a company and draws a minimal salary — the standard reconsideration may not be sufficient. For an existing calculation, a variation application is made under section 28G of the Child Support Act 1991, which applies the section 28A variation rules. The guide explains when to pursue reconsideration and when variation is the right route.
Free Download
Get the CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist
Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.
What a Good Receiving-Parent Guide Covers
The CMS Mandatory Reconsideration guide covers both parents, and for receiving parents specifically:
- Counter-evidence framework — your right to submit evidence when the paying parent challenges a decision, what the CMS shares with you about their submission, and how to respond before the review closes
- Evidence-to-input matching — which documents actually displace the paying parent's claims for each disputed input (income, shared care, additional children)
- When reconsideration vs variation applies — if the dispute is about income diversion or hidden assets rather than a simple factual error, the guide explains the boundary
- The receiving parent's enforcement position — what stays in force during the review, and what happens to your payments if the decision changes
- HMRC income walkthrough — why the CMS uses historic tax data, how the annual review works, and why a sudden drop in the paying parent's income figure might be legitimate (or might not be)
- Domestic safety chapter — alternative submission routes, evidence handling, and third-party representation for parents who cannot safely contact the CMS directly or whose contact details need to be protected
It includes printable worksheets: a deadline calculator, an evidence schedule, a submission record log, and a contacts directory covering Citizens Advice, Gingerbread, legal aid, and the Family Mediation Council.
Who This Is For
- Receiving parents whose maintenance dropped because the paying parent reported lower income or more shared care
- Receiving parents responding to a reconsideration the paying parent started
- Receiving parents who believe the paying parent is hiding income through self-employment or a company structure
- Family members or friends helping a receiving parent who is overwhelmed by the process or close to the deadline
- Parents in domestic abuse situations who need to know about alternative submission channels and third-party representation
Who This Is NOT For
- Receiving parents whose dispute is about enforcement or arrears rather than the calculation itself — that's a different process (collection and enforcement, not reconsideration)
- Parents in Northern Ireland — CMSNI is a separate jurisdiction
- Anyone looking for a solicitor to handle the entire process — the guide is a self-navigation tool, not legal representation
Frequently Asked Questions
Does the paying parent's challenge mean my payments will stop?
No. The existing calculation stays in force while the mandatory reconsideration is processed. The paying parent is still required to pay the current amount. If the reconsideration changes the figure, the new amount applies from the effective date — which could mean a retroactive adjustment in either direction.
I don't have access to the paying parent's payslips — how can I challenge their income claim?
You don't need their payslips directly. The CMS holds the HMRC income data and can request updated records. Your role is to present any evidence that the declared income doesn't match reality — lifestyle indicators, Companies House records, evidence of employment or business activity. For complex income-hiding situations, a variation application may be more effective than a standard reconsideration.
Can I request a mandatory reconsideration if I'm the receiving parent?
Yes. Both parents have the same statutory right to request a reconsideration within 30 days of the decision letter. This isn't limited to paying parents disputing their assessment — if your maintenance was reduced and you believe the figures are wrong, you can challenge it through exactly the same process.
What if the paying parent stops paying during the reconsideration?
The obligation to pay continues during the review. If the paying parent stops paying, the CMS can move the case to Collect & Pay (with a 20% collection surcharge on the paying parent and a 4% deduction from your payment) and enforce through Deduction from Earnings Orders or other measures. Report missed payments to the CMS — don't wait for the reconsideration to resolve first.
Is there free help specifically for receiving parents?
Gingerbread's Advice Service closed on 1 April 2025; its information pages and community membership remain available. Citizens Advice provides impartial guidance for both parents. Legal aid does not fund ordinary benefits appeals to the First-tier Tribunal, though specified related family-law matters, including some domestic-abuse cases, may qualify subject to scope and financial eligibility rules. The guide lists these resources with current contact details.
Get Your Free CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist
Download the CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.