What Happens After Mandatory Reconsideration CMS: Outcomes and Next Steps
The Mandatory Reconsideration Notice
When the CMS finishes reviewing your case, it sends a formal document called a Mandatory Reconsideration Notice (MRN). This sets out the outcome and the reasoning behind it.
The MRN is an important document. Keep it somewhere safe — you'll need it if you decide to appeal to the tribunal.
Outcomes and Related Decisions
Decision revised: The CMS agrees the original calculation was wrong and replaces it. A revision takes effect from the original decision date, meaning arrears or overpayments are adjusted retroactively. The CMS may allocate an overpayment against arrears or ongoing maintenance, but allocation is discretionary; reimbursement is not automatic. If you've been underpaying, the difference is added as arrears.
Separate change-of-circumstances decision: A relevant change since the original decision is handled through a supersession, not as an outcome of the mandatory reconsideration. The effective date depends on the type of change and the applicable rule.
Decision upheld: The CMS confirms that the original calculation was correct. The existing payment amount continues unchanged.
Late request refused: If you applied after the 30-day deadline, the CMS may decide that the special circumstances test for a late extension wasn't met. The original decision stands.
How Long Does It Take?
There's no statutory time limit on how quickly the CMS must complete a mandatory reconsideration. DWP told Parliament that in the quarter ending September 2025, an average of 96% of new applications were cleared within 12 weeks and 83% of changes of circumstances within 28 days. These are CMS service targets, not mandatory-reconsideration time limits.
In practice, straightforward cases (a clear income error with strong evidence) may be resolved within a few weeks. Complex cases involving shared care disputes, self-employment income, or cases where the other parent's response needs to be considered can take longer.
If the CMS is taking significantly longer than expected, your options are limited. Administrative delays don't give you grounds to bypass mandatory reconsideration and go straight to the tribunal. You can escalate through the DWP complaints process or contact your MP for assistance, but neither will speed up the actual recalculation.
Free Download
Get the CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist
Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.
If the Decision Goes Against You
If the CMS upholds the original decision (or makes a change you still disagree with), you can appeal to the First-tier Tribunal (Social Entitlement Chamber).
Key details:
- Deadline: Within one month of receiving your Mandatory Reconsideration Notice
- Form: SSCS2 (specific to child maintenance — the online SSCS1 form is for other benefits)
- Cost: Free — no court fees apply
- Late appeals: A tribunal judge may grant a discretionary extension of up to 13 months from the MRN date
The tribunal is fully independent of the CMS and DWP. It conducts its own hearing (usually oral, though paper hearings are possible), examines all the evidence, and can substitute its own decision. Both parents are parties to the appeal, and all evidence is shared.
Payments Continue Regardless
Throughout the reconsideration and any subsequent appeal, the existing payment schedule stays in force. The paying parent must keep paying the amount currently set by the CMS until a formal outcome changes it. Stopping or reducing payments will cause arrears to accumulate.
For a complete guide to the mandatory reconsideration process — from initial request through to tribunal preparation — see our CMS Mandatory Reconsideration guide.
Get Your Free CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist
Download the CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.