CMS Shared Care Nights Dispute: Challenging the Overnight Calculation
How Shared Care Changes the Calculation
For Basic, Basic Plus and Reduced rate calculations, the CMS reduces the paying parent's maintenance liability based on overnight stays. The reduction works in bands:
- 52–103 nights (average 1–2 nights per week): 1/7th reduction
- 104–155 nights (average 2–3 nights per week): 2/7ths reduction
- 156–174 nights (average 3–4 nights per week): 3/7ths reduction
- 175 or more nights: reduce the amount by half, then deduct a further £7 a week for each child in this band
For Basic or Reduced rate calculations, payments cannot fall below £7 a week after shared care is applied.
The difference between bands can be significant. Moving between the first three bands changes the reduction by a seventh of the basic rate; the 175-or-more band has a separate 50% reduction and an extra £7 weekly reduction per child.
Why Overnight Numbers Get Disputed
Shared care disputes are among the most common reasons for mandatory reconsiderations. If a child stays with each parent for roughly the same amount of time, the CMS asks both parents for information about the care arrangements and may ask for supporting evidence. That creates room for disagreement.
Typical disputes arise when:
- One parent reports a different number of overnights than the other
- Actual care patterns have changed since a court order was made but no formal update has happened
- School holidays, illness, or family events create irregular patterns that don't fit neatly into weekly averages
- A child stays overnight somewhere else and the parents disagree over who was responsible for the child that night
One Reddit user described being assessed at £290 per month based on the other parent telling the CMS he had their child three nights a week. His actual pattern was seven nights per fortnight — 50/50 during term time and holidays. His mandatory reconsideration failed, and he was weighing a tribunal appeal.
What Evidence Works
A court Child Arrangements Order can be submitted as evidence of the care pattern. The CMS bases its shared-care reduction on the number of nights the child actually stays with each parent.
Without a court order, the CMS can accept a formal agreement (for example, one drawn up by a solicitor) or another official document, such as a CAFCASS or social services report. It cannot accept communication only between the parents, photos, social-media screenshots, or calendar entries as evidence of overnight shared care.
The CMS looks at actual care, not what was agreed in principle. If you can demonstrate a consistent pattern of overnights that puts you in a different band, that's what matters.
Free Download
Get the CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist
Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.
Equal (50/50) Shared Care
If a child stays with the paying parent for 175 or more nights a year, the shared-care reduction is half the amount, plus a further £7 a week reduction for that child. Equal overnight stays do not automatically mean that no maintenance is payable; the CMS also considers who provides most of the day-to-day care.
Keep a record of how many nights the child stays with each parent. A change that moves the weekly average into a different shared-care band can change the reduction.
How to Challenge
Request a mandatory reconsideration within 30 days of the decision letter. Specify that the shared care band is wrong, state the number of overnights you can evidence, and attach your documentation.
The CMS contacts both parents when either reports a change to overnight stays. It asks the other parent to respond with information about the change and any supporting evidence, then reviews the information.
For a full guide to challenging shared care errors — including overnight tracking tools and evidence schedules — see our CMS Mandatory Reconsideration guide.
Get Your Free CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist
Download the CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.