$0 CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist

Child Maintenance Calculation Wrong: How to Challenge a CMS Decision

Why CMS Calculations Go Wrong

The Child Maintenance Service calculates maintenance using income data from HMRC, usually the latest available gross income information. It takes account of pension contributions and other children, applies the rate for the paying parent's income band and number of children, then applies any shared-care reduction. The Basic rate is 12% for one child, 16% for two, and 19% for three or more.

That means errors usually come from one of a few sources:

  • Outdated HMRC income figures — the CMS usually uses the latest available gross income information from HMRC, which may differ from current earnings after a job change
  • Wrong shared care band — the CMS records a different number of overnight stays than what actually happens
  • Missing relevant children — children in the paying parent's current household who should reduce the basic rate weren't counted
  • Incorrect pension deductions — eligible pension contributions weren't deducted from gross income before the calculation

First: Identify What's Actually Wrong

Before you challenge anything, compare the figures on your decision letter against what you know to be true. The letter should show the gross income figure used, the shared care adjustment (if any), and how many qualifying children are counted.

Work out which specific input is wrong. "The amount seems too high" isn't grounds for a mandatory reconsideration — "the CMS used £45,000 gross income but my actual earnings were £32,000 after a one-off capital gain was wrongly included" is.

Gather Your Evidence

Each type of error needs specific evidence:

Income errors: P60, P45, consecutive payslips, employment contract, or SA302 tax calculation summaries from HMRC. If you're self-employed, audited trading accounts and your tax calculation are essential.

Shared care errors: For overnight shared care, the CMS can accept a current court order, a formal agreement (for example, one drawn up by a solicitor), or another official document such as a CAFCASS or social services report.

Household children errors: Child Benefit award notices, birth certificates, or adoption documentation showing children living in the paying parent's current household.

Free Download

Get the CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist

Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.

Request a Mandatory Reconsideration

You have 30 days from the date on your decision letter. Submit your request through your My Child Maintenance Case online account, by phone on 0800 171 2345, or by post to Child Maintenance Service 21, Mail Handling Site A, Wolverhampton, WV98 2BU.

Your request should:

  1. Quote the exact date and reference number from your decision letter
  2. State that you're requesting a mandatory reconsideration
  3. Explain precisely what input is wrong and why
  4. Attach your supporting evidence

If your evidence isn't ready yet, file a protective request before the deadline explaining your grounds and what you're still collecting.

A Common Trap: HMRC Corrections

If the CMS used an incorrect HMRC income figure, you might think correcting it with HMRC will fix the problem. It won't — at least not automatically. Amending your tax return with HMRC is a separate process that doesn't trigger a CMS recalculation or extend your 30-day deadline.

You need to request a mandatory reconsideration directly with the CMS and supply copies of your corrected tax documents (like an SA302) as evidence. Do both in parallel, but don't wait for HMRC to finish before filing with the CMS.

Keep Paying

While your challenge is being reviewed, the existing payment amount stays in force. Stopping or reducing payments unilaterally will cause arrears to build up, and the CMS may take collection or enforcement action depending on your circumstances and payment route.

For a complete, step-by-step guide to challenging a CMS calculation — including evidence checklists and deadline trackers — see our CMS Mandatory Reconsideration guide.

Get Your Free CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist

Download the CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.

Learn More →