$0 CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist

Paying Parent Mandatory Reconsideration CMS

When to Challenge as a Paying Parent

As a paying parent (called the non-resident parent in CMS terminology), you have the same statutory right to request a mandatory reconsideration as the receiving parent. If your CMS calculation letter contains an error — wrong income figure, incorrect shared care band, or a missing adjustment for a child you or your partner receive Child Benefit for — you can ask the CMS to look at the decision again.

The most common triggers for paying parents include:

  • Wrong HMRC income figure or tax year: a one-off bonus or earnings from a job you no longer hold do not by themselves make the historic HMRC figure wrong
  • Shared care nights not counted: you have your children overnight regularly, but the CMS recorded fewer nights than actually happen
  • Other children not included: children you or your partner receive Child Benefit for may be taken into account, but the CMS missed them
  • Default maintenance decision: if the CMS could not get income information, it may have used a default weekly rate based on the number of children in the case

Your Rights During the Review

Filing a mandatory reconsideration does not pause your obligation to pay. The existing maintenance amount stays in force until a revised decision formally changes it. Missing payments while the review is pending can trigger enforcement action — the CMS may move your case to Collect & Pay (with a 20% collection fee added to your liability) or apply a Deduction from Earnings Order through your employer.

If the amount feels unmanageable, free debt advice from StepChange (0800 138 1111) or National Debtline (0808 808 4000) can help you manage household finances while you wait for the outcome. National Debtline says it will not share your details. StepChange may share information with creditors involved in a debt solution.

Building Your Evidence

The CMS revises decisions based on verified documents, not explanations. For income disputes, the strongest evidence includes:

  • P60 for the relevant tax year
  • Consecutive monthly payslips showing current actual earnings
  • SA302 tax calculation from HMRC if you are self-employed or have mixed income
  • Employer contract confirming your current salary

For overnight shared-care disputes, CMS accepts a current court order, a formal agreement such as one made through a solicitor, or another official document such as one from CAFCASS or social services. It does not accept parent-to-parent messages, photos, social media screenshots, calendar entries, or school records as evidence of overnight stays.

Label every document with your name, National Insurance number, and CMS case reference.

Free Download

Get the CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist

Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.

How to Submit

You have 30 days from the date on the decision letter. Submit through:

  • Your CMS online account
  • By phone: 0800 171 2345
  • By post: Child Maintenance Service 21, Mail Handling Site A, Wolverhampton WV98 2BU

Whichever channel you use, state that you are requesting a mandatory reconsideration, identify the exact decision by date and amount, explain what is wrong, and attach your evidence.

If you post it, use Royal Mail Signed For and keep the tracking receipt. A written request must arrive within the deadline, so allow time for delivery.

What Happens to the Other Parent

The CMS shares your submission with the receiving parent and gives them a chance to respond, usually within 14 days. Personal contact details, your address, and employer information are redacted before disclosure.

Both parents are equal parties throughout. The decision maker reviews everything from both sides before issuing the Mandatory Reconsideration Notice.

Our CMS Mandatory Reconsideration guide covers every step from identifying the error through to preparing for a tribunal appeal if the CMS upholds its decision.

Get Your Free CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist

Download the CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.

Learn More →