$0 CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist

CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Evidence: What You Need to Submit

Evidence Is What Changes the Decision

The CMS already has a file on your case. When you request a mandatory reconsideration, the decision maker reviews the information on file and any relevant new evidence you submit. Evidence can help show why the decision should change.

The strength of your reconsideration depends almost entirely on the quality and relevance of your documents.

Match Your Evidence to the Disputed Input

CMS calculations are built from specific inputs — gross income, shared care nights, relevant other children, pension deductions. Your evidence needs to target the exact input you're challenging.

Gross employment income: P60 for the relevant tax year, P45 from a previous employer, consecutive monthly payslips, or your employment contract showing current salary. The CMS pulls income data from HMRC, so if the HMRC figure is wrong, you need documents that show what the correct figure should be.

Self-employment income: SA302 tax calculation summary from HMRC, full tax return, or audited trading accounts. Self-employed income is particularly prone to dispute because HMRC records may not capture recent changes in trading profit.

Shared care nights: When supporting evidence is needed for a disputed overnight shared-care change, the CMS can only accept a current court order, a formal agreement (for example, one drawn up by a solicitor), or another official document such as a CAFCASS or social services report. The CMS bases the reduction on the number of overnight stays (52–103 nights, 104–155 nights, and so on), so provide evidence that supports the number of nights.

Relevant other children: Child Benefit award letters, birth certificates, or adoption documentation proving that children in the paying parent's current household qualify as relevant other children for the calculation.

Pension contributions: Statements showing personal pension contributions paid directly by the paying parent. Occupational pension contributions are already taken into account in the income figure used by the CMS.

How to Present Your Evidence

Label every document clearly. Each item should show your full name, date of birth, and National Insurance number so the CMS can match it to your case file. Unlabelled documents risk being separated from your request during processing.

Create a simple evidence schedule — a numbered list of what you're sending, the date of each document, and what fact it proves. For example:

  1. P60 (2025-26) — shows gross earnings of £31,500
  2. Employment contract dated 1 April 2026 — confirms current salary of £30,000
  3. Current court order — shows the overnight shared-care arrangement

This isn't a legal requirement, but it makes the decision maker's job significantly easier and reduces the chance of anything being overlooked.

Free Download

Get the CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist

Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.

New Evidence the CMS Didn't Have Before

You can submit evidence that wasn't available when the original decision was made. This is one of the main reasons mandatory reconsideration exists — to catch errors caused by incomplete or outdated information.

If HMRC's records were wrong and you've since received a corrected SA302, include it. If a court order was issued after the CMS decision, submit it. The decision maker considers everything that's relevant, regardless of when it was produced.

What Won't Work

General statements about your financial situation or unverified claims about the other parent's lifestyle aren't effective evidence. For overnight shared care, the CMS cannot accept communication only between parents, photos, social-media screenshots, or calendar entries; use a current court order, formal agreement, or another official document.

For a full evidence checklist and submission tracking tools, see our CMS Mandatory Reconsideration guide.

Get Your Free CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist

Download the CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.

Learn More →