$0 CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist

CMS Collect and Pay Challenge

What Collect & Pay Means

When a paying parent misses payments or the CMS decides Direct Pay is not working, it can move the case to Collect & Pay. Under this arrangement, the CMS collects maintenance directly from the paying parent and passes it to the receiving parent — but both sides pay fees.

Under the current rules, the paying parent's liability increases by 20% (a collection fee on top of the calculated maintenance), and the receiving parent has 4% deducted from each payment received. These fees are significant: on a £300/month calculation, the paying parent owes £360 and the receiving parent receives £288.

Can You Challenge the Move to Collect & Pay?

The payment method is an administrative issue, not an appealable maintenance-calculation decision. If the move was based on incorrect payment information, ask the CMS to correct its records or make a complaint. Use a mandatory reconsideration to challenge the maintenance amount.

The grounds that matter most are factual:

  • Payments were actually made on time: if you can show bank transfer records, standing order confirmations, or receipts proving consistent Direct Pay payments, the CMS may have acted on incorrect information
  • A one-off missed payment had a specific cause: a bank error, illness, or communication breakdown rather than a pattern of non-compliance
  • The receiving parent reported non-payment incorrectly: sometimes Direct Pay disputes arise from confusion over timing or amounts rather than actual missed payments

Attach dated bank statements or transfer confirmations showing every payment made, with the amount and date clearly visible.

The 20% Fee Is Not a Fine

The 20% collection fee is built into the statutory Collect & Pay framework — it is not a penalty imposed for a specific offence. Once you are on Collect & Pay, the fee applies to every payment regardless of whether you pay on time going forward. Either parent can ask the CMS to change a Collect & Pay arrangement to Direct Pay. The CMS will make the change unless it has reason to believe doing so would not be in the child's best interests.

The government announced proposed changes to Collect & Pay fees in June 2025 — including a reduced fee structure for compliant paying parents — but these changes have not been enacted as of late 2026. The current 20%/4% fee structure remains in force.

Free Download

Get the CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist

Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.

What If the Underlying Calculation Is Also Wrong?

Collect & Pay fees are calculated on top of the maintenance amount. If that underlying amount is itself incorrect — wrong income figure, wrong shared care band — challenge the calculation through a mandatory reconsideration, and raise an unjustified payment-method change with CMS as an administrative complaint.

Be specific about which decisions you are challenging. The CMS issues separate decision letters for the calculation and for the payment method. Reference the date and reference number on each letter when you submit.

Our CMS Mandatory Reconsideration guide explains how to structure challenges against multiple related decisions and keep track of overlapping deadlines.

Receiving Parents and Collect & Pay

Receiving parents can also request that the CMS move a case to Collect & Pay if the paying parent is not making Direct Pay payments reliably. If you have asked and the CMS refused, provide evidence of missed or late payments, such as bank statements showing the expected amounts did not arrive, and raise the issue with the CMS through its complaints process.

Section 1 of the Child Support Collection (Domestic Abuse) Act 2023 would allow the CMS to arrange collection where there is evidence of relevant domestic abuse, but that section is not yet in force.

Get Your Free CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist

Download the CMS Mandatory Reconsideration Checklist — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.

Learn More →